About Us

For over thirty years, Nina’s Custard has been a family owned and operated restaurant. In April, 1990 Nina’s Custard was opened as a small seasonal hotdog and custard stand by Antoinette “Nina” Scioli and her children, Anthony and Susan. This small stand was operated for ten years, until our present location was built in 2000 at 2577 Millersport Highway, Getzville, New York. The new location offers an expanded menu along with year round indoor seating, and two patios.

Today you can still find Nina’s children, Anthony, Susan, daughter-in-law Mary, and grandchildren operating and serving you the same delicious Sahlen’s Hotdogs and frozen custard. We thank you for all the years of business.

Curbside Takeout

Pickup your next order from the comfort of your car. Order online or over the phone, then call us when you arrive and we will deliver your order to your car.

Orders Made to Order

All our orders are made to order so you get the freshest food every time. Hot food hot and cold treats cold.



Homemade Ice Cream Cakes

Our Ice Cream Cakes are homemade and can be customized to your taste. We have some of our favorites ready in our display case for your immediate enjoyment. The most common flavors are Turtle, Peanut Butter Cup, M&M, Sprinkles, Cookies n Cream. Custom cakes require 24 hours notice.

Mobile Online Ordering

We are happy to offer online ordering. Please visit http://www.toasttab.com/ninascustard

Catering & Events

Let us cater your next event. Corporate events, family parties, school fundraising, or birthday parties we have you covered.