Nina's Custard
2577 Millersport Hwy, Getzville, NY
Featured Items
Menu
Dogs
Burgers
Sandwich
- BBQ Chicken Sandwich$7.99
- Chicken Sandwich$7.99
- Fish Sandwich$7.75
- Meatball Sandwich$6.75OUT OF STOCK
- Panini - Cheese$7.25
- Panini - Chicken$9.89
- Panini - Meat$10.50
- Panini - Tuna$10.50
- Panini - Veggie$10.50
- Roast Beef$8.25
- Tuna Sandwich$6.80
- Chicken Salad Sand.$7.25
- Chicken Finger Sand.$7.50
- Italian Sausage$6.95
Cones
- Custard - Baby$3.31
- Hard Ice Cream - Baby (one scoop)$3.77
- Fat Free Soft - Baby$3.31
- Oat Milk-Baby$3.31OUT OF STOCK
- Oat Milk Twist-Baby$3.10
- Dole -& Lemon Ice Twist Baby$3.31
- Dole Whip-Baby$3.31
- Custard - Regular$4.28
- Hard Ice Cream - Regular (2 scoops)$5.29
- Fat Free - Soft Regular$4.28
- Oat Milk$4.28
- oat milk twist$4.28
- Dole & Lemon Ice Twist Regular$4.28
- Regular Dole Whip$4.28
- Custard - Large$5.01
- Hard Ice Cream - Large (3 scoops)$6.25
- Fat Free Soft - Large$5.01
- Yogurt - Large$4.83
- Yogurt Twist - Large$4.83
- Dole & Lemon Ice Twist Large$5.01
- Large Dole Whip$5.01
- Custard - Giant$5.98
- Hard Ice Cream - Giant (4 scoops)$7.22
- Fat Free Soft - Giant$5.79
- Yogurt - Giant$5.98
- Yogurt Twist - Giant$5.98
- Dole - Giant$5.79
- Giant Dole /Lemon Ice Twist$5.98
- Waffle Custard$5.50
- Waffle Hard Ice Cream$6.70
- Waffle Fat Free = Soft$5.50
- Waffle Yogurt$5.50
- Waffle Dole$5.50
- Vanilla EDIBLE Doggie Dish (Baby SIze)
Edible Dog Dish With Vanilla (Baby SIze)
$2.99 - Vanilla Doggie Dish (Baby Size)$2.57
Sundaes
- Sundae - Baby Custard$4.50
- Sundae- Baby Hard Ice Cream$4.75
- Sundae - Baby oat milk$4.35
- Sundae - Baby Fat Free - Soft$4.50
- Sundae - Baby Fat Free Twist$4.35
- Sundae - Baby Dole$4.50
- Sundae-Baby Lemon Ice
- Sundae - Regular Custard$5.95
- Sundae - Regular Hard Ice Cream$5.95
- Sundae - Regular Oat Milk$4.97
- Sundae - Regular Fat Free - Soft$5.95
- Sundae - Reg Fat Free Twist$5.95
- Sundae - Regular Dole$5.95
- Sundae - Large Custard$6.99
- Sundae - Large Hard Ice Cream$7.40
- Sundae - Large Oat Milk$6.85
- Sundae - Large Fat Free$6.99
- Sundae - Large Fat Free Twist$6.85
- Sundae - Large Dole$6.99
- Sundae- Large Lemon Ice
- Specialty Sundae - Baby$5.25
- Specialty Sundae - Regular$6.99
- Specialty Sundae - Large$7.99
- #1 Banana Split - Custard$7.99
- #2 Banana Split - Custard$7.99
- #1 Banana Split - Fat Free - Soft$7.99
- #2 Banana Split - Fat Free = Soft$7.99
- #1 Banana Split - Yogurt$7.99
- #2 Banana Split - Yogurt$7.99
- #1 Banana Split - Dole$7.99
- #2 Banana Split - Dole$7.99
- #1 Banana Split Hard Ice Cream$8.25
- #2 Banana Split Hard Ice Cream$8.25
- Apple Crisp Sundae (1 Size)$8.25
Kids
Sides
- Apple Sauce (Side)$0.95
- Garlic Toast$0.85
- Macaroni & Cheese$5.75
- Potato Chips$0.85
- Roll$0.75
- Side Cheese$0.75
- Side Dressing$0.75
- Soup - Bowl$5.75
- Soup - Quart$11.99
- Tuna macaroni Salad$3.00OUT OF STOCK
- Gluten free roll$1.99
- Peppers And Onions$0.50
- Extra Piece Chicken$5.00
- quart mama roses dressing$11.99
- texas sauce$0.80
- double extra peppers and onions$0.90
- extra lettuce$0.30
- extra tomato$0.35
- pint mama roses dressing$8.75
Fryer
- Chicken Fingers - 3$7.50
- Chicken Fingers - 7$14.20
- Criss Cut Fries$3.95
- Fried Dough$5.95
- Mozzarella Sticks$7.50
- Onion Rings$4.75
- Pizza Logs$9.25
- Straight Fries$3.75
- Sweet Potato Fries$4.99
- Coconut Shrimp (4)
Indulge in a tropical delight with our Coconut Shrimp served with a tantalizing Sweet Chili Sauce.
$8.49OUT OF STOCK
Novelty
- Ice Cream Sandwich$2.65
- Ice Cream Sandwich - 6 Pack$14.25
- Nina Bar$4.60
- Turtle Bar$4.60
- Pint - Custard$5.99
- Pint - Dole$6.25
- Pint - Lemon Ice$6.25
- Pint - Fat Free No Sugar$6.25
- Quart - Custard$9.50
- Quart - Dole$9.50
- Quart - Lemon Ice$9.50
- Quart - Fat Free, No Sugar$9.50
- Cookie$1.99
- Brownie$0.85
- Waffle Plain Cone$0.70
- Waffle Chocolate Dipped Cone$1.30
- Waffle Choc Nuts Or Sprinkles$1.80
- Extra Cone$0.20
- Quart - Yogurt$8.80OUT OF STOCK
- large size hot fudge$2.45
- Chocolate Chip Cookie - Happy Orchard
Crispy on the outside, soft and chewy in the middle, and bursting with chocolatey goodness. 25% less added sugar Than Our classic chocolate chip cookie*
$2.99 - Chocolate Fudge Brownie Happy Orchard
Decadent, rich, and oh-so-fudgy. Your new favorite way to get a chocolate fix. 25% less added sugar Than Our classic FUDGE BROWNIE*
$2.99 - Banana Chocolate Chip Muffin Loaf - Happy Orchard
A perfect harmony of ripe bananas and indulgent chocolate chips in every bite. 25% less added sugar Than Our classic CHOCOLATE CHIP MUFFIN*
$2.99
Combo Meals
Drinks
- Soda - Regular$2.99
- Shake - Regular$5.25
- Shake - Regular - Malted$5.99
- Float - Regular$5.25
- Soda - Ice Cream - Regular$4.95
- Slush - Regular$2.95OUT OF STOCK
- hot choc
- Milk$1.65
- Milk - Chocolate$1.65
- Apple Juice$1.75
- water
- Soda - Large$3.49
- Shake - Large$6.15
- Shake - Large - Malted$6.90
- Float - Large$6.15
- Soda - Ice Cream - Large$6.15
- Slush - Large$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Slush - Baby$2.25OUT OF STOCK
- Shake - Baby$3.30
- Milk$1.65
- Milk - Chocolate$1.65
- Bottle Water$2.50
- rasp ice tea$3.25
- 20 oz Bottles$4.50
- Bottle Water$2.50
- Frappucino oat milk$4.50
- double shot$4.50
- Cappuccino$2.99
- Coffee$1.99
- Coffee - Decaf$1.99
- Hot Chocolate$1.99
- Tea - Hot$1.99
Salad
#2 Banana Split - Custard
SUNDAES
SUNDAES
Custard Choices
Required*
Please select 1
Sundae Extras
Nina's Custard Location and Hours
(716) 636-0345
Open now • Closes at 10PM